Support

Legal Review: D.C. Events Promoter and Arena Manager Attempt to Shift Liability to Plaintiff

By a D.C. Injury Attorney with Price Benowitz LLP

In any personal injury or wrongful death lawsuit, one of the primary issues is whether the plaintiff had any responsibility to try and avoid injury or death. Did the plaintiff exercise proper care? Did they act in a manner that led to their injury or death?

These issues, often described as “contributory negligence”, are used by defendants in civil suits to try and shift some or all of the liability for the injury or death back to the plaintiff, thereby avoiding some or all of the responsibility.

In any situation where someone suffers an injury or dies, a certain amount of second guessing is unavoidable and many times decisions that led to the outcome can be identified.

Fortunately, the law does not dabble in second-guessing or speculation. It deals with duty and responsibility. Whenever someone suffers an injury or dies, the question is not what could have been done differently, the question is whether the parties met the legal standards in question.

In the case of James Truesdale, who fell to his death from scaffolding at RFK Stadium in Washington, D.C. while setting up for a Foo Fighters concert, these issues of negligence, duty and contributory negligence all come into play.

Mr. Truesdale’s daughter is seeking to hold his employers responsible for not providing the proper safety and construction equipment to her father, thereby causing his fall to result in death. His employers are seeking to show that Mr. Truesdale’s actions themselves led to his death and that the safety and construction equipment had nothing to do with it.

It will be up to the jury, after hearing all the evidence, to decide who was ultimately responsible. The District of Columbia is a pure contributory negligence jurisdiction, which means that if the plaintiff was even a little bit at fault in their injury or death, the defendant can avoid all liability.

If this seems harsh, it is because most jurisdictions do not recognize this form of contributory negligence. Most jurisdictions recognize comparative negligence, which takes into account the degree to which someone is responsible for their injuries and reduces any compensation accordingly.

“The District’s rules on contributory negligence are antiquated and very defendant-friendly,” said wrongful death attorney Maxwell Paderewski. “Any time a case can be filed in another jurisdiction with more plaintiff-friendly laws, it should be considered. Sometimes, however, a case cannot be moved, and the Plaintiff must be ready to defend any and all contributory negligence claims.”

Recent Stories

700 V Street, NW at 7th/Georgia Ave Holy smokes, thanks to B. for sending the Torrie’s listing: “Restaurant for lease in Shaw. First time available in over 30 years,

1817 Columbia Road, NW Not just Namak! A couple storefronts down Easy Tiger Tavern has sprouted some new signage/awning:

Wegmans is located off Wisconsin in rear at 41 Ridge Square, NW Last year’s was awesome. Mark your calendars – April 5-6!! “Experience the excitement of Tokyo’s famed Toyosu Fish…

2000 Pennsylvania Ave, NW Thanks to Brian for sending: “The Paul at 2000 Penn has closed as of last Saturday, not many left at this point!” Looks like the only…

Calling all bookworms, thrill-seekers, supporters of the arts, and ping-pongers at all skill levels! Sign up for Paddlestar Galactica, the ping-pong tournament supporting 826DC’s youth writing programs.

826DC is a local nonprofit that offers free writing programs, homework help, and publishing opportunities for DC students ages 6-18, in our Columbia Heights writing center and in learning spaces across the city.

Paddlestar Galactica helps keep writing education 100% free and accessible for all of our students! It’s also extremely fun.

This year’s games will be Saturday, April 27th, 1 PM to 4 PM at SPIN DC. It’ll be a chaotic afternoon of ping-pong, costumes, terrible Battlestar Galactica puns, and good cheer. We’d love to have you join us!

Read More

Submit your own Announcement here.

Well-Paid Maids, the only certified living-wage cleaning service in the DMV, has added a new service to its online booking menu: office and building cleanings.

This includes offices, building lobbies, shared amenity spaces and more throughout D.C., Arlington, Alexandria and more.

Unlike so many other cleaning services, you can feel good booking Well-Paid Maids to clean your office or building. Cleaners get paid a starting wage of $24 an hour. Plus, all employees are offered health, dental, vision and life insurance; 24 paid days off per year; 100% employer-paid commuting costs; and more.

Read More

Submit your own Announcement here.

Vakili Band at Pie Shop!

Three band rock n rolll lineup at DC’s Pie Shop! Vakili Band with “if you know, you know” DC rockers, Lot 18, and the many minds and songs of artist Kind of Christine.

“If you love Vakili Band like we

×

Subscribe to our mailing list