“Missing some Brunswick Stew in DC”

by Prince Of Petworth October 24, 2016 at 1:45 pm 14 Comments

Photo from flickr by Joe Loong

“This cooler weather has me craving Brunswick Stew again, and back home around this time of year, I could always count on picking some up at my or other local churches. I think some of the local clubs sold it also.

I’ve tried making it several times, but I can never get the recipe right, so I’ve accepted the fact that I should just go back to buying it.

Does anyone know of local churches or clubs who sell some amazing Brunswick Stew? Thanks!”

You can see all forum topics and add your own here. If you are having trouble uploading your question please email me at princeofpetworth(at)gmail Please Note this is NOT an events calendar.

  • Andrew Lisi

    The best is definitely at the Sweet Home Cafe at NMAACH, if you can get in.

  • tmcoll

    Not easily accessible but Sweet Home Café has traditional (with rabbit) Brunswick stew. Also check Due South. If all else fails, Mrs. Fearnow’s in the yellow can isn’t bad…

    • Glover Park

      Where have you found Mrs. Fearnow’s?????? Totally agree, but I can only get that online or in Richmond!

      • greg

        You can usually find it at Harris Teeter

      • dcduchess

        I just saw it this weekend at Aldi’s on 17th ST NE.

  • Summer209

    My significant other and I have discovered that there is a Georgia version and a Virginia version of Brunswick stew (I love/miss the southern VA version that I used to get at churches and Ruritan clubs in the fall). Due South definitely falls in the GA category (more barbecue-based). Any idea what category the Sweet Home Cafe version falls in?

    • Anon

      Agreed. I tried this at Due South when they were still in “soft opening” phase or very soon after they opened and it tasted like barbecue soup. Not at all like what I was used to from BBQ joints in North Carolina, where it’s more of a tomato broth with pork and lima beans and other veggies. I’ve looked for this for more than a decade in DC and have never seen anything worth remembering.

      (Looking for a bright side: Maybe sometimes it’s nice to think that a regional food stay regional?)

    • houseintherear

      My mom called it “New Brunswick Stew,” which could just be her error but that’s what our family called it in Yorktown! Maybe “New” is the Va version?

  • Welshi

    The problem with Sweet Home Cafe is Brunswick stew is made with leftover bbq bits- it should be cheap- not $16! That’s crazy talk.

    I’d love to find some good ol’ Brunswick stew in DC too! Hell, I’d even take mediocre stew if it came with some hush puppies for dipping. Alas, I think a good stew first requires a place to make good bbq pork… which, as we know, is a whole other discussion.

    I kinda agree with Anon- it’s a special treat I’ll reserve for visits to NC.

  • Kate

    Martin’s Tavern has had brunswick stew on the menu for decades.

  • The thing with stews is that they are all pretty much the same basic ingredients and techniques, but with enough slight variations in seasoning & flavor that they also have very specific associations/memories, so whatever version your granny/church supper gave you is the one you crave – and will never find again because it only exists in memory.

  • OP here… Thanks for the comments everyone. I’m definitely going to try it when we go to the NMAACH (even at $16), but I was really hoping to find local clubs or churches where I can buy it by the quart. There’s something nostalgic about buying it at a local church or club and just hanging out with the “cooks” for 15 – 30 minutes.
    Being from RVA, the Due South version would probably have left me very disappointed, and it doesn’t seem to be on the menu anymore.
    I was hoping it would have made it this far north, but I guess not. I’ll try the Post recipe, but I’ll also make sure we take a large cooler when we visit the family for the holidays.

  • Truxtoner

    I have some in my freezer right now. I buy some whenever I can and bring it back to DC (from southern VA) and freeze it to try to get them through the season. Maybe I should start selling it up here in DC! Ha.


Subscribe to our mailing list