Dangerously Delicious Pies Looking Good

by Prince Of Petworth April 19, 2010 at 4:30 pm 24 Comments

Even though they’ve only been open for a week or so, the word is out on this spot because the place was packed on Friday night. They are located at 1339 H St, NE (near the Star & Shamrock) and you can see their menus here. I’ve spoken to folks who say that the pies are phenomenal. Anyone check them out yet?

More photos after the jump.

  • petworthlad

    Two questions: Do they have meat pies? (Looks like all American-style pies, not British…) And why are they using disposable aluminum pie pans? That’s a lot of non-recylable pans.

    • Yes, they have meat pies. Their revolving menu is on their website. I like both the steak & gruyere.

    • West Kansas

      Not recycleable? I thought aluminum was by far the most recyclable material out there.

      • Dave

        It’s definitely recyclable, and for all we know, these pans could be made from recycled aluminum.

    • Marco

      I was suspect about the high prices as well but the savory slices (7.50 including tax) are as filling as a Taylor Sub so Im a believer— I suppose the first people buying Starbucks balked at the price and now its the norm.

  • Anonymous

    If you pay $28 for a pie, kill yourself by eating the pie on metro tracks somewhere on the red line.

  • Caro

    Anyone know what the price range is per slice, as opposed to whole pie?

  • Oh no that blueberry pie looks watery and the top isn’t browned at all… not exactly mouth watering in my book… I will reserve full judgment until I eat it though…

    • I don’t think that’s blueberry. I could be wrong, but I think that’s the Marion Berry(sic) Pie, which is some kind of berry pie w/ rock candy on top (which is why I think the crust looks like that – it’s the rock candy).

      • Mal

        That’s hilarious! I want to go, just to say I had a slice of Marion B[a]rry and finished it off with some rocks…

      • Haha I see. Well now I have to try that too.

    • Kate

      Actually that’s the sour cherry pie. It was delicious.

  • Amsterdam

    $28 for a pie is way steep, and I guarantee my grandma’s is better.

  • heisenburg

    Slices are between $6-$7.50. Kinda expensive, but the pie is amazing, the photos don’t do it justice. probably a good thing, the high price, otherwise we’d be a bunch of lard butts around H St.

    • Stephanie

      Lard butts…I like it.

  • anon

    While it seems like a lot of money for a slice of savory pie, I have now gone two nights and been full from one slice both times.

    IMHO, $7 for a darn tasty meal is not bad.

  • x

    whenever you pay 28 dollars for an apple pie, an amish person laughs at your idiocy


    I am trying to stay in shape and work on getting my abs. Showing me these good looking pies isn’t helping my cause and to keep my manly physique. LOL

    I love french apple pie.



    I am trying to stay in shape and work on getting my abs tight.

  • grant

    I did it last week….baltimore bomb on the employees recommendation. I wasn’t that impressed and really wanted to be. Crust was good, maybe just the wrong flavor

  • Warderite

    That berry pie looks like a tutorial in how not to make pie… dry, under-browned crust with runny, watery filling. It looks like they’re either not putting enough flour/pectin/whatever in, or they’re serving them before they’re cool. Gross.

    This Southerner has high standards for pie. I don’t think I’ll be dropping $28 for a watery mess there anytime soon.

  • gardyloo

    The very best thickener for a fruit pie, sadly lacking here, is tapioca. The small kind of tapioca, not pearl tapioca (aka fish eyeballs). Good in bubble tea, not so much in pies.

    A quarter cup in a 9″ cherry or blueberry pie is about right. Peach pie–maybe a heaping tablespoon. Same with strawberry-rhubarb.

    Also the pie above seems to be lacking in vents in the top crust, especially around the perimeter.

  • PLEASE OPEN A STORE ALONG 14th/U STREETS, PLS PLS PLS. (Don’t worry, we’re all working on that city cap on eateries). Tried their pie this wknd, and just about fainted. It’s that good.

  • This opening is amazing. A month ago, I actually blogged about wanting hipster chefs to abandon cupcakes in favor of other dessert shops, even outlining why a pie shop specifically would appeal to their sensibilities. And now here it is! Wonderful.


Subscribe to our mailing list