I’ve had various luck with things over the year, depending on how frustrated I was feeling. I always use glue traps for mice.
1. Cashews. Don’t know why, but my mice liked them a lot.
2. Just straight up poison. The poison block baits that are supposed to be refills, I would put them in the center of the glue trap and it would kill them either on the trap or near it. Not feasible with children or animals around, though.